| Team | Year | Coach | COY Bowl | Playoff Recap |
 | 2007 | Anthony Tangorra | Defeats Miami Dolphins 27-24 | Recap |
 | 2008 | Dennis Crowley | Defeats Baltimore Ravens 30-24 | Recap |
| 2009 | Dennis Crowley | Defeats Seattle Seahawks 31-14 | Recap |
 | 2010 | Harlan McLain | Defeats Cleveland Browns 23-17 | Recap |
 | 2011 | Jason Goldberg | Defeats Washington Redskins 20-17 | Recap |
 | 2012 | Dan Suhr | Defeats Tampa Bay Buccaneers 23-17 | Recap |
| 2013 | Anthony Tangorra | Defeats New York Jets 20-17 | Recap |
 | 2014 | Nathan Wheeler | Defeats Tennessee Titans 31-28 | Recap |
| 2015 | Harlan McLain | Defeats Houston Texans 24-13 | Recap |
| 2016 | Dan Suhr | Defeats San Diego Chargers 26-24 | Recap |
 | 2017 | Mike Martin | Defeats Indianapolis Colts 26-20 | Recap |
| 2018 | Tom Veltry | Defeats Green Bay Packers 38-33 | Recap |
 | 2019 | Scott Kaplan | Defeats New York Jets 33-10 | Recap |
 | 2020 | Jeff Wendlandt | Defeats Philadelphia Eagles 23 – 21 | Recap |
 | 2021 | David Kukafka | Defeats New York Giants 27-10 | Recap |
| 2022 | Dan Suhr | Defeats Indianapolis Colts 31-10 | Recap |
 | 2023 | Jess Geller | Defeats New England Patriots 21-14. | Recap |
